Protection Order Defense Attorney
Defending Against Protection Orders in Washington
If you've been accused of harassment, domestic violence, stalking, or sexual assault in Washington, you may suddenly find yourself facing a protection order that restricts your freedom and tarnishes your reputation. At Marshall & Saunders, we understand how frustrating this experience can be.
As skilled defense attorneys with decades of in-the-trenches experience, we've helped countless clients navigate the complex legal system and push back against unwarranted allegations. We know there are two sides to every situation, and we're here to make sure yours is heard.
Whether you're a respondent who's been unfairly accused or a petitioner seeking to protect yourself from a genuine threat, we have the knowledge and dedication to advocate fiercely for your rights. Trust us to guide you through this challenging time with skill, compassion, and unwavering support.
What Qualifies as a Protection Order?
The Essence of Protection Order Cases
Protection orders in Washington take several forms depending on the situation and relationship between the parties. While each type has specific requirements and serves important purposes, they can also be misused or sought without proper justification.
A domestic violence protection order (DVPO) can be issued when there is evidence of domestic violence between family or household members. Sexual assault protection orders (SAPO) protect victims from further contact with alleged perpetrators, while stalking protection orders (SPO) require evidence of stalking behavior and a reasonable fear of harm.
Anti-harassment orders (AHPO), another common type, require proof that someone has suffered "unlawful harassment" — conduct that seriously alarms, annoys, harasses, or is detrimental to them without legitimate purpose. These orders can be particularly problematic because they rely heavily on subjective interpretations of behavior. We've defended many clients who faced harassment allegations for ordinary interactions, misunderstandings, or unintentional encounters. What one person perceives as harassment might be completely innocent conduct taken out of context.
For any type of protection order, the law requires evidence that would cause a reasonable person to suffer substantial emotional distress or, in cases involving children, would cause a reasonable parent to fear for their child's well-being. However, this "reasonable person" standard can be interpreted differently by different judges, making it crucial to have experienced legal representation to present your side of the story effectively.
Washington Law on Protection Orders
There are several types of protection orders recognized by Washington state law, each of which is designed to address specific situations based on the relationship between the parties and the nature of the threat or harassment. The standard of proof is lower for a petitioner in a protection order case than it is for a criminal case. Rather than needing to prove their allegations beyond a reasonable doubt, a petitioner only must show that it is more likely than not that the offensive conduct occurred.
Here’s an overview of the various kinds of protection orders available in Washington:
- Domestic violence protection orders: Issued when the petitioner shows that the respondent has committed an act of domestic violence.
- Sexual assault protection orders: Issued when the petitioner shows that the respondent sexually assaulted them.
- Anti-harassment orders: Issued when the petitioner proves unlawful harassment that seriously alarms, annoys, or is detrimental to them.
- Stalking protection orders: Issued when the petitioner proves stalking and a reasonable fear of injury.
- Vulnerable adult protection orders: Issued to protect seniors or other vulnerable adults from abuse, neglect, or financial exploitation.
- Extreme risk protection orders (“red flag” laws): Issued to prevent individuals who might seek to harm themselves or others from obtaining or possessing firearms.
Sometimes, the petitioner and the respondent come to a compromise before the official hearing through a written agreement. As part of this agreement, the respondent usually agrees to limit their behavior in some way. In return, the petitioner agrees not to seek a full protection order.
Agreements like this usually need to be arranged by attorneys for both parties. That’s because they’re negotiated while the temporary order is in effect, and the temporary order usually prohibits the respondent from having any communication or other contact with the petitioner. In this case, the respondent can only communicate through their attorney.
Penalties for Protection Orders
A civil protection order alone cannot put you in jail, but the consequences can be significant. In addition to having to disclose the order to some employers, a judge or commissioner can order you to treatment. These orders can affect custody of your children or your ability to live in your own house. Firearm rights are often compromised by protection orders.
Most protection orders expire around one year after they’re issued. Sometimes, they’re granted for longer periods. In some cases, they can even be permanent.
Orders that aren’t permanent can be extended, though this can only happen if the petitioner applies for an extension shortly before the order expires.
While it’s relatively easy for a petitioner to get a temporary order, the courts won’t endlessly indulge those who file groundless petitions. The law generally prohibits issuing a temporary order to someone who has already received two temporary orders against the same respondent without convincing a court to issue a full order.
Other Potential Consequences
Violating a protection order is a crime. A respondent who does so can be arrested immediately and be subject to criminal prosecution. A conviction could mean facing penalties like fines and jail time on top of the protection order.
Get Help Fighting a Protection Order
Facing a protection order petition? Don't wait — we can help. Our team understands the urgency and will fight to protect your rights. Whether it's domestic violence, harassment, or any other accusation, we'll build a strong defense and fight to clear your name and give you peace of mind.
Key Challenges in Defending Against Protection Orders
Defending against any type of protection order presents unique challenges. The courts often err on the side of granting these orders, making a strong defense essential. Here are some of the key challenges you may face:
Inconsistent Court Standards
Washington courts are inconsistent in what evidence they allow in protection order proceedings. Some will permit little else but testimony by the petitioner and the respondent and will severely limit cross-examination. Others will hear testimony from third parties and allow full cross-examination.
Compelling Evidence Against You
In every court, the first testimony must come in writing in the form of the initial petition. In the petition, the person seeking the protection order reports the facts that they believe justify issuing an order.
The respondent typically submits a declaration, or sworn written testimony, in response to the petition. In some cases, the petitioner can submit another declaration in reply to the respondent's declaration.
If the petitioner presents evidence suggesting that they have a good reason for pursuing a protection order, it may be tough for the respondent’s defense team to overcome.
Concurrent Criminal Proceedings
If the respondent is under criminal investigation or prosecution for the acts alleged in the petition, they may elect to exercise their right to remain silent in the criminal case.
However, if they refuse to answer questions in the protection order case, the court is free to infer that the withheld testimony would have supported the petition. This creates a dilemma for the respondent. Recent changes in the law have made it more difficult to continue protection orders until a criminal case is resolved.
Rape Shield Law
In sexual assault protection order cases, Washington’s “rape shield law” limits the evidence a respondent can present about the petitioner’s sexual behavior or history, requiring cumbersome procedures to admit such evidence.
Potential Defenses Against Protection Orders
There are several effective defenses that can be raised against protection order petitions. Here are some of the strategies our attorneys employ most often:
Insufficient Evidence
The petitioner must convince the judge their claims are more likely true than not. If the evidence is weak or contradictory or lacks credibility, this can be a strong defense.
No Legitimate Purpose
In cases involving anti-harassment protection orders (AHPOs), a key defense is showing that the respondent's actions served a legitimate or lawful purpose, even if they caused the petitioner distress.
Petitioner's Conduct
Evidence that the petitioner engaged in mutually combative behavior or provoked the respondent's actions can undermine their claim.
Improper Motive
If the evidence suggests that the petition was filed for an improper purpose, such as to gain advantage in a divorce or child custody dispute, it can undermine the petitioner’s case.
Word from a Client We Helped
Calm, smart and efficient attorney.
Josh Saunders is the attorney you want when dealing with extremely vexatious and false litigations. Im wrapped in a hell of a family law motion with a very vexatious opposing party. He was able to immediately get on a call with me on a Sunday on a referral from another attorney and talked me through the next steps. Once i retained him he took the time to go over the entirety of the case. He knows when and how to work with investigators and prosecutors to provide the right amount of detail at different stages of the case. Example he was able to get on a call with the investigator as well as email threads with the prosectuor at the right time to provide the documents needed without overloading the detail. He is smart, efficient and knows how to prioritize aspects of a case and proper steps to mitigate the situation. He is always there when in an emergency as all aspects of criminal cases always feel like an emergency, He is transparent and guides you through the process, very open to questions and approaches he wishes to take and overall I feel like he always has my back. He also understands nuances of South East asian marriages and customs very well which is always an added bonus. Overall, definitely recommend him especially in clutch situations. He got my case dismissed at a critical juncture.
Protection Order Petition Isn’t the Last Word
Being served with a petition for a protection order can be vexing, but there are options. Our empathetic attorneys are prepared to advocate fiercely on your behalf and protect your rights throughout the ensuing legal battle.
Our Process for Defending Against Protection Orders
At Marshall & Saunders, we take a strategic, multi-faceted approach to defending clients against protection orders. Here's what you can expect:
Why Choose Us as Your Protection Order Defense Law Firm?
Choosing the right lawyer is critical when you're staring down the severe consequences of a protection order. Marshall & Saunders brings unparalleled experience and dedication to every case, offering clients the following advantages:
- Extensive experience with protection order cases
- Shrewd analysis of complex evidence and witness testimony
- Diligent case preparation and persuasive courtroom advocacy
- Helpful guidance on collateral criminal issues
- Empathetic, non-judgmental support during difficult times
You need a strong defense to protect your rights, relationships, and reputation. Marshall & Saunders can give it to you.
Take Control of Your Future
Being labeled as a dangerous person can impact your life in countless ways, all of them negative. Don't let the petitioner control the narrative. Contact us today to schedule a confidential consultation and get a skilled team of legal defenders on your side.
Call us now at (206) 826-1400 or fill out our online contact form to claim your consultation.
901 Fifth Avenue, Suite 2800
Seattle, Washington 98164
You will receive a response from us within 1 - 2 business days.